Tribal Council Judgement Guide ...
Tribal Council Judgement Guide
This is the guide used by your classmates to judge the quality of your presentation. You will also use this same judgement guide to judge the quality of the presentations by the other groups. Notice how important it is to provide sources for your information. The tribal council expects you to PROOVE that your information came from reliable sources. In order to do this you can first evaluate the web page and image content you find using the handy guides provided for evaluating web pages and images. Then you can provide a list of sources and the reasons you feel that those sources are reliable!
white belt |
yellow belt 50% to 64% |
blue belt 65% to 74% |
red belt 75% to 84% |
black belt 85% to 100% |
|
| Quality of information | There was very little or no information. Information was completely inaccurate. The council is displeased. | The information was not accurate all the time and no sources were shown for the information. The council expects better. | Most of the information was accurate, but no sources for the information were shown. The tribal council feels you could improve the quality of your proof. | The information was accurate, but not all sources for the information were shown... so the council cannot determine if the information is of good quality. | The information was completely accurate and came from reliable sources. All sources of information were shown so the council can be sure of the quality of the information. |
| Quality of presentation | Your presentation was uninteresting and of very poor quality. You have failed your tribe! | Very little effort was made to give an interesting and engaging presentation. Information provided was just copied and pasted from web pages. The council is not impressed. | Information has been adapted from web pages instead of copied. Your presentation is interesting, and the visuals adequate, but the flow is not smooth. The tribal council suggests you practice presenting beforehand next time. | Information has been adapted from web pages instead of copied. Your interpretation of the information is interesting. The tribal council is impressed with your presentation, it flows smoothly and the visuals are of good quality. | You have summarised information from web pages instead of copying it. You clearly understand what you have presented. The presentation was interesting and engaging. There was a smooth flow of information using good quality visuals and a creative approach. The tribal council considers your team to be grand masters! |
| Tribal council judgement | Information gathered was not sufficient to protect the tribe and they will perish. |
Information gathered was not enough to ensure tribal safety or advancement. |
Information gathered will help in some areas but will not protect us from invaders. |
Information gathered will help the tribe advance in many areas for the time being.
|
Information gathered will ensure survival of the tribe and contribute to its growth.
|
| Final belt awarded the tribal council | white belt Less than 50% |
yellow belt 50% to 64% |
blue belt 65% to 74% |
red belt 75% to 84% |
black belt 85% to 100% |
